September 20, 2005

  • Hmmm…interesting discussion.  But let me add my own argument.

    Regarding the ease of believing Christianity, sure it is easy. 
    All I have to do is believe God exists, created the world, loves me and
    sent Jesus to die for me and everything is alright (though if that was
    all Christians REALLY expected people to believe, Christianity would
    not be near as controversial).  However, just because something is
    easy to believe doesn’t mean it is true.  Have you heard of
    jumping to conclusions?  The whole reason it happens is because
    people assume something is true just because it is easy to believe, yet
    they are wrong.  What’s to say it’s not the same with God? 
    Sure, I have heard the argument that it takes more faith to believe in
    the Big Bang and evolution because they require you to believe in a
    series of coincidences, whereas believing in Creation only requires
    believing in God.  However, ease of belief is not what defines
    something as true; evidence is.  The
    evidence doesn’t lie.

    When it comes to blind faith, I believe people who rely totally on
    blind faith are living the Christian delusion to the max.  All
    faith requires at least some level of rationalization, and blind faith
    has absolutely no rationalization at all.  Blind faith is based
    totally on circumstantial evidence, which does not hold up in
    court.  Think about the chair analogy.  People use the
    analogy to say that you have to have faith in the chair to hold you
    up.  True, but I am not sitting in the chair because of blind
    faith.  I have seen many other people sit in chairs, even people
    that are heavier than me, and it has held them up.  I can examine
    the structure of the chair and see that it is able to support my
    weight.  Therefore, I am not sitting in the chair because of
    faith.  I am sitting in it because I have evidence that it will
    hold me up.

    When it comes to being happy, I suppose that Christians are happy
    because of their beliefs.  But that does not make their beliefs
    true.  All that means is that they have been brainwashed or
    deluded themselves into being happy.  To say that someone will
    only be happy when they become a Christian because Christians are happy
    is circular reasoning.  If you step outside of the Bible for a
    minute, how do you really know that everyone out there who does not
    believe in Christianity is not really happy?  And if any of them
    are happy, then why must they change to something else and risk being
    unhappy?  Besides, just because you are happier than you have ever
    felt before from being a Christian doesn’t mean there is not something
    else out there that could make you even more happy.

    I do not know if there is anybody out there for me to marry, and right
    now I don’t think there is.  I want there to be that special
    someone, but I don’t think there is.  I don’t even know if I
    believe in love anymore.  All I am looking for in a relationship
    right now is just casual sex.  That may sound crude, but right now
    I see no reason to give up my freedom for the rest of my life just
    because it is the “right thing to do.”  I don’t want children
    because I fully believe I would be a bad parent and fuck them up for
    life.

    I have heard the argument (and used it many times) about Christianity
    being “a relationship, not a religion.”  True, I think faith has a
    lot to do with relationships.  However, I think the main reason I
    do not want a relationship with God or whatever is very similar to my
    reasoning for not wanting to be married.  I see no reason for
    giving up my freedom by getting married, and I see no reason for giving
    up my freedom by turning my life over to Jesus just for the chance that
    it MIGHT get me to Heaven (sure, I know you say it WILL get me to
    Heaven, but what proof do you have besides the Bible that Heaven even
    exists?).  And also, just a subpoint, if Christianity is not all
    about this life’s purpose being to prepare us for the next life, then
    why do Christians witness and become missionaries?  Your whole
    life has become consumed by trying to win converts to your religion.

    Finally, the risk involved in believing in God versus not believing in
    God.  I don’t know how many times I used that argument with
    non-Christians.  Sure, maybe I have more to fear from being wrong
    than you do.  But just because I have more to lose from being
    wrong does not mean I AM wrong.  If you are wrong, maybe you have
    lost less, but you were still wrong.  Wouldn’t you be upset at
    wasting your life believing something that wasn’t true?

Comments (7)

  • I am intrigued by your point (which you have made numerous times) that being a Christian means being brainwashed.  I personally do not feel I was brainwashed nor manipulated into my choice of belief.  I made a rational choice to believe the Bible and follow its teachings.  I am curious why you make a lump-sum comment about the Christian faith.  If you are stating that Christians have been brainwashed then I feel you are going to have to go ahead and include all major religions in this field.  I guess I am wondering if you look at your Christian friends ( say our mutual old roommate John Adams) and see a person who is dellusional and walking around wasting his life?  Just curious.

    And, as a married man, I would like to offer up the point that I did not loose freedom once I devoted my life to my wife.  Their is ultimate freedom to be me in my marriage and this is deeply beautiful.  And the truth is I have not lost the freedom to do whatever I want.  If I really wanted to go out and find different women to have causal sex with, I could.  Just because I wear a ring on my finger does not prevent me from this “freedom.”  Marriage isn’t the end all of end alls when it comes to personal freedoms.  Instead, it is the devotion of honesty, trust, and intimacy to another and making the choice to love them day in and day out.

  • I would like to focus on George’s point of christianity being people that are deluded and brainwashed.  This is so incredibly true.  I mean when you think about it, what makes Christians any different from Psychos.  They’re both delusional.  They both talk to people and things that aren’t there, or they don’t know are there.     

  • Hmm… some good points, yes even justin’s have been good as well. But about brainwashed, how exactly do you think people are “brainwashed?” There is a high level of conscious choice. If there wasn’t, then why do you not believe? It is nearly impossible for someone who is brainwashed to actually “see the error of their ways.” If there is a choice to stop believing at any time, then I don’t think it qualifies at brainwashing.

    As for delusional, that is a possibility as well? I think not. Read a psychology book. Delusional people don’t just stop believing (on their own) that the imaginary thing stop existing. It requires years of therapy from a psychologist, and possibly some medication. However, people on medication for things that treat the same symptoms still believe in God. Why? If they are delusional, then why would they still believe in something that doesn’t exist if they are on meds that keep them from those beliefs?

    Plus, delusions don’t stop at believing in things that others can’t see. They actually see things that don’t exist, or hallucinate. Then, there are a bunch of other things that accompany those symptoms I can’t remember. And not all are the same, some can have one set of symptoms while another has a completely different set. One thing does hold true, they do not have rational thoughts, ever.

    If Christians were truly delusional, then they couldn’t hold normal jobs, if any at all. They wouldn’t be able to take care of themselves or other people (children, family members, etc.)

    It is possible to be very wrong about a belief without being brainwashed or delusional.

    Christianity is not easy to believe. I admit, it takes a lot to believe in something that “might” not exist. There are a lot of choices out there. The choices that are made are made in faith. One has faith in many gods, while others may believe in just one, others have faith in no god and some have faith that they are a god. Believing there is no god still requires some faith, faith that you are correct in assuming there is no god.

    Evidence is not in favor of belief. Belief requires much more than evidence. Like I said before, you believe in things that might not be true everyday. For instance, your car starting. You believe that when you turn the switch it will start. There is no evidence that the car will start today just because it did yesterday. There is a possiblity that the starter went out, or the battery died. I realize that it is easily remedied but it still requires a system of beliefs.

    I am sure my arguements mean little here but I am trying my best for the analogy that fits with your mind that things you take for granted everyday still have some level of belief behind them. Though those beliefs seem concrete on the surface, there is truly no evidence that can prove that things as they exist today will be the same tomorrow.

    There is no scientific proof that God exists. I’m not sure there ever will be if you rely on a scientific answer. One cannot put a god inside a box to find out if it is real or the only one. People believe what they believe for a reason. They don’t need science to confirm what they believe.

    One thing I notice of my faith versus scientists, I don’t care how much they prove their beliefs, in my mind I have a sense of what is right and wrong and I believe what I believe without need to litmus test everything in sight. If that makes me more gullible, fine. I cannot say that what they prove is wrong. I support their effort for finding out where we come from. I hope that they are satisfied with what they believe, and I hope they realize that I am satisfied with what I believe.

    I cannot discount or retort their evidences. It is quite possible that the Bible does not give a full picture of creation but does that mean I should stop believing in it? As far as I know we both could be right. Does it mean I am decieved if God made man by way of the scientific method, I’m not sure it does. It only means that someone could not put into words something that did not exist at the time.

    But can science prove God does not exsist if they can’t prove He does? They can find evidence of the Bible being wrong through its entirety, but they cannot prove God does not exist; they can only prove that a bunch of people wrote some really good stories that aren’t true.

    There is however evidence that things form the Bible do exist. At least, Josephus thought that a man named Jesus, who claimed to be the Messiah existed, that he did die exactly the way it is presented in the Bible, and also that His body disappeared after His death. But can one prove whether Jesus was right or wrong?

    It is much more difficult to test beliefs. There is no evidence that those beliefs even exist unless they are mentioned. Yet, you don’t question whether or not people can have beliefs. Maybe that’s because you have beliefs also and thus require no proof that others have them when they tell you they do. But how do you know for sure? I could tell you that I believe aliens exist, and you could not test whether or not I have that belief. There is no evidence except my statement. It would not hold up in court that I made that statement if all you had was your word against mine.

    You could test me on how much I believe that statment. But the degree to which I believe the statement is a dependant variable. The independant variable would be the test; how the questions are phrased, what questions you ask, how many questions you ask, what scale you use, all of that will determine the outcome of the test. But the simple fact remains that the belief itself cannot be tested, therefore it can either exist or not exist.

  • cool

  • Ok, I can’t comment much because I’m supposed to be writing a paper, but your post is too much to pass up…and I’m a procrastinator.

    First paragraph–very good points, I agree. What’s easy to believe isn’t always true.

    Second paragraph–you’re right, blind faith is irrational. But look at the logical conclusion of your argument. You have faith in a chair because you see it support other people, even those heavier than you. Do you not see Christ support other people? Haven’t you seen people’s lives change drastically? Haven’t you seen people have amazing peace in the middle of terrible times? Could they be deceiving you? Sure. So could the person pretending to sit in a chair. You have to examine your sources, weigh probabilities, question witnesses, balance possible outcomes, test potential solutions, etc. I hate to see people with blind faith. Is their faith real? It could be, I guess, but they’re still blind. I’d rather have a logical, reasoned faith in something I’ve found to be true. I’d rather have my eyes open. Keep searching with an honest hunger for the truth, and I think you’ll find what you’re looking for.

    Ok, I’d like to write more, but I must be responsible–hehe, can I say that as I write a paper due in less than 5 hrs? Anyway, you’re always welcome to call–or drive up now that gas prices are lower. We should definitely hang out.

  • I don’t have time to post on this entire comment, but I will make one statement.  It seems that you have made one very large misinterpretation about Christians being happy.  Nowhere in the Bible does it say that you will be happy as a Christian.  In fact, it says you will suffer.  Christ promised joy and I know you know the difference.  Happiness is a choice.  You can choose to be happy in your circumstances, or you can choose to be depressed.  Don’t however, think that anyone has said or suggested that being a Christian should make your life here on Earth easier or happier.  That is a falasy.

  • In response to sbugradmay, and the patients that are on meds.  The medication obviously isn’t working. 

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *