June 10, 2006
-
Why does a belief in aliens so often coincide with a disbelief in
God? Why does a belief in God so often coincide with a disbelief
in aliens? Both require an element of faith, yet each group mocks
the other, saying it is stupid to have such a belief.Now you have to admit that it is logically absurd to hold a belief in
God when all of the proof of His existence is circumstantial at
best. Many believers in God do not have any basis for believing
other than faith. Some are more of the thinking type, coming up
with rational arguments to support the existence of a God. One of
the most popular is saying that everything had to start somewhere, and
since the first law of thermodynamics says that something can’t come
from nothing, even the Big Bang had to have an origin somewhere.
An intelligent creator or creators only makes sense (of course, that only begs the question of where they came from).On the other hand, a belief in little green men can be seen as equally
absurd, especially since we have no proof other than that which has
allegedly been covered up. Many of the people who believe in
aliens simply want it to be true and don’t think about it
logically. The thinkers of the group (most of them in the
scientific community) have their own rational arguments. One of
the biggest is that even with the odds of our evolution being so
infinitessimal, such a large universe opens up all sorts of
possibilities of intelligent life on other worlds. With so many
galaxies with all of their billions of stars, it only stands to reason
that at least a few of those would have planets capable of supporting
life, and some of those planets would have lifeforms with comparable
intelligence to our own.Neither of these groups really has any concrete evidence to support
their claims, yet they stick to their guns nevertheless. Is it
really so undermining to religion to believe in aliens? After
all, couldn’t God have decided He liked creating life so much that He
decided to do it some more? Why create such a large universe if
you are only going to use one little speck of it? It’s like
buying a ream of paper to write the letter “a” on one sheet. What a
waste. Then again, however, why are the aliens people and the
scientific community so adamantly against a belief in God? If
there is life on other planets, that doesn’t necessarily point to the
existence of God. However, if aliens do exist, we can pretty much
guarantee that we are not the most technologically advanced of all
lifeforms in the universe. It is logically possible that an alien
species out there could have been so much more advanced that it created
our planet and/or planted the seeds of life on the planet. It is
also possible that they could be so advanced that they have left this
dimension entirely, essentially becoming gods themselves.The funny thing is is that both of these groups share one belief, and
that is the belief in some sense of order to all things. The
religious people believe in divine intervention, where a Creator set
things in motion and guided them to be the way they are now. The
aliens/scientific people believe that everything happened by chance,
but they still hold to laws and theories as the governing agents of the
universe.This just brings us back to the age-old science vs. God
argument. I think religious people are afraid that adopting any
kind of
scientific rationale means they are leaving God and turning to the
futile explanations of men. I think scientific people are afraid
of believing in God because it would mean chucking their brain out the
window and relying on pure faith. Neither is
true, yet I think so many people believe it nonetheless. Both of
these groups are afraid of opening their mind up at all for fear that
everything they have stood for their entire lives would be wrong.I do not think that science and faith have to be mutually exclusive.
Comments (5)
Well said–especially that last sentence. I see no reason why there couldn’t be aliens. However, I haven’t seen any evidence that they’ve visited earth.
I think you’re right, George. A belief in God should not preclude a belief in life on other planets.
I too agree that science and faith aren’t mutually exclusive. Good thoughts.
muy bien.
And I applied for that job at O’Reilly, but never heard anything.
I still disagree with your premise that belief in God is absurd in the absence of scientific evidence. Given what all cultures affirm about the divine – that God is SUPER-natural – it would be foolish to expect science – which only informs us about the natural – to be able to inform us in any way about God or his/her nature. Only those who live within an Enlightenment worldview insist on scientific evidence for God.
And I also do not identify with your statement that those who believe in God are closeminded toward science. I myself have a strong belief in God and love to keep up with current scientific advancements. In fact, I beleive that science is the best tool we’ve developed to explore the creation God has given us. It is God who invited us to explore that creation – many of the greatest early scientists were believers and chased their discoveries precisely because they loved God.
As for the aliens – you’re right that both God and aliens are faith-based. That’s what makes Signs such a cool movie – proving aliens ends up proving God.
There are religious studies scholars who compare modern abduction accounts with medieval Christ visions. Interesting, eh?